Tl;dr
- Using notifications to let customers know about upcoming events can be a powerful way to create awareness of campaigns. However, if not executed correctly, they can backfire and lead to lost sales.
- Marketing orchestration is an underrated part of the job. When done right, itās invisible. But hereās what happens when itās notā¦
[Aside: this was originally going to be a short post about this one little banner, but then it turned into a rollercoaster ride of errors, bad requested, something about a wish list and a looooong list of things that went wrong).
Iāve been looking to replace my snowboard for some time now. I wanted something a little faster, a little more fun, and just⦠new.
After hours of research, reading reviews, and endless comparisons, I settled on the Burton Process Camber. I was ready to buy!
Since Iāve had good experiences buying directly from Burton before, I preferred to purchase from them again.
Things Fall Apart
On Wednesday March 5th, I logged onto the Burton site, credit card in hand, and was greeted by a bright pink banner.
āSale starts March 6āsave up to 40%.ā
Wait⦠what? I can save money if I donāt buy it now?
Remember - I was ready to buy: research done, credit card in hand. My motivation and intention were at their peak. But this banner changed everything. If I bought the board immediately, I would be losing the 40% discount. That single moment triggered loss aversion, and just like thatāmy motivation vanished.
The Paradox of Choice by Barry Schwarz
The Risk of Delayed Sales
A customer like me might leave the site intending to return later. But thereās an equally strong chance Iād forget or buy elsewhere. Deferring the sale this way is a risky move by Burton, though some brands successfully use anticipation tactics to drive urgency. However, in this case, the execution seemed to create confusion rather than build excitement.
The next dayā¦
I remembered the sale and decided to go back to the site. Instead of heading directly to Burtonās website, I searched for the board on Google.
Thatās when things got worse.
First - the top search results werenāt from Burton. When I finally found a Burton.com link, it led to a page where the board wasnāt even in stock.
[I get it - SEO is hard and you canāt guarantee the the top spot - but the campaign they were pushing was relying on me actively coming back to the site. And for a lot of people, including me in this case, that means going to Google.]
As it turns out, the product page that is ranking for this search term is for the 2023 version of the board, which Burton no longer keeps in stock (even though it says itās on sale!)
A few extra things happened at this point
- My previously very high intention and motivation evaporated even further. Seeing the discounted 2023 model made me wonder: Do I really need the 2024 version? Should I hunt for the older board instead?! Seeing the old board at the reduced price put me back in research and comparison mode!
- I left the burton site and started googling the older board to see if I could find a better deal.
This whole situation suggests a disconnect between Burtonās marketing, SEO, and website teams.
Back on the search results page, I clicked on another Burton link, hoping for better luck. But instead, I found myself on yet another page where no discount was applied.
The Bannerās Fatal Flaws
By this point, I had waited an entire dayāonly to find that the promotion wasnāt even available on all product pages.
Had I delayed my purchase for no reason?
This kind of marketing misstep is costly. If a sale banner is shown site-wide, it must apply to every relevant product. Otherwise, it leads to confusion, frustration, and lost sales.
I should clarify that at this point I was still actually trying to buy this board! They told me to come back on March 6, I did the thing! And yet I canāt buy the boardā¦
It was only by clicking on the sale banner, and then using the search banner for Men > Snowboards that I was able to get to the sale version of the board.
Okay, thereās a lot to unpack here, but fist ā back to the banner.
How This Could Have Been Done Better
- Only show the banner when the sale is live. Customers buying today wouldnāt know about it, ensuring the sale goes through.
- Give customers an action to take. Instead of telling me to come back later, why not ask me to register or sign up to get early access? This would keep me engaged and ensure I return.
- Ensure the banner applies to all relevant products. If some products arenāt included in the sale, they shouldnāt display the banner.
- Improve marketing coordination. Misalignment between teams leads to customer confusion. A more coordinated approach could have prevented this mess.
The Psychological Impact of Poor Execution
Burtonās mistake wasnāt just technicalāit was psychological. The marketing team failed to account for loss aversionand underestimated the effort customers put into researching high-ticket items.
Once a customer reaches a high-intent state, any frictionāwhether a confusing discount, a broken link, or an out-of-stock productācan derail the sale completely. For a premium product priced at several hundred euros, this is a dangerous mistake.
Final Thoughts
Iām not without sympathy for Burton. Iāve been on the other side of marketing mishaps before. But this was a preventable failure.
The reality? I still havenāt bought the board.
For other companies, this serves as a reminder of how critical marketing coordination is. A poorly executed campaign can confuse customers and derail high-intent purchases. Ensuring clear communication between teams, aligning promotions across platforms, and reducing unnecessary friction can make all the difference between securing a sale and losing one.
Better luck next time, Burton. I hope you didnāt shred too many sales.
Lester
Update: It got worse. When I later visited the page which was displayed in the search results, I was greeted with a rather inelegant ā400 Bad Requestā error page.
Clicking the second result was just as bad (maybe worse because it has more unintelligible stuff on it).
Some more things happened at this point:
- I was questioning whether the Burton site was broken
- Even knowing that there is probably some internal marketing tech going on behind the scenes, I STILL wondered about the safety and security of the site. Some base level, primal thing was making me nervous
Iām sure there are a whole host of things going on at Burton - stuff like staging environments, deployment processes, go live procedures, agency coordination and other internal things.
Like I said - Iāve been there and personally messed up in ways that are worse than whatās happening here (but not much worse tbh; this be bad).
And I STILL havenāt bought this boardā¦
šSome References and Further Reading about the behavioural marketing topics in this piece
1. Robert Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion
āA well-known principle of human behavior says that when we do someone a favor, we expect something in return. Businesses can use this to their advantage by providing small incentives upfront to increase the likelihood of customer commitment.ā
š This supports the idea that Burton could have used an immediate incentive (such as early access for registered users) instead of a delayed discount, which led to lost momentum in the purchase journey.
2. Uri Gneezy, Mixed Signals: How Incentives Really Work
āFacts are dry: ā$450 discount if you buy the car today.ā But context and framing determine how people perceive incentives. Losses weigh heavier than gains, and the wrong framing can turn a deal into a deterrent.ā
š This reinforces the point about Loss AversionāBurtonās banner inadvertently framed the purchase as a loss today, rather than a gain tomorrow.
3. Sheena Iyengar, The Art of Choosing
āWhen we speak of choice, what we mean is the ability to act on our desires without barriers. The moment complexity is introduced, the desire to choose decreases.ā
š This aligns with the discussion on decision fatigue and frictionāBurtonās poor website experience and scattered product pages made the buying process unnecessarily complicated, reducing the likelihood of conversion.
Disclaimer: some items on this post contain affiliate links and I may earn a commission if you buy. There is not change to the price for you
Update: I bought the board! I wonder if that means I need to change this post now š¤
Latest
More from the site
Lester
music
Now Playing: Hot Fuss - The Killers
I first heard this album while walking past Musica (a CD store in South Africa) - I heard the riff from āSomebody Told Meā blaring from the store PA and that was enough to hook me. Intrigued, I went
Read post
Lester
reading
Getting Things Done: Going back to the well time and time again
GTD and how I snuck my way to competence
Read post
Lester
marketing
The Psychology of āEveryoneās Doing ItāāAnd Why It Sells. Anchoring and Social proof for marketers.
Use Anchoring and Social Proof to become a better behavioural marketer
Read post